levik
2003-08-25 19:19:05 |
Comment editing
Not sure if anyone noticed, but as of today, Stunents and up can now edit their comments. (The "edit" link appears next to the "Reply" link under the comment.
For now, only the editing of the comment body (not subject or "marker") is allowed.
Thank DJ for requesting this much needed addition. |
Gamer
2003-08-25 22:37:21 |
Re: Comment editing
I am unsure comment editing is such a good thing. Suppose someone changes their comment so they have the right answer? Other things could come up too. I would suggest putting something editted in later in italics or something else distinguishable but not distracting. |
levik
2003-08-26 00:02:01 |
Re: Comment editing
Right now, the last edit date is appended to the end of the comment after editing. I believe that since this is only open to Students and up, there should not be too much immature behavior. After all, comments don't really count for much in the way of granting privileges on the site, so in the end run, is it really horrible for the site if somebody goed and fixes their solution after reading an official one? |
DJ
2003-08-26 09:12:00 |
Re: Comment editing
Yeah, if you're just going to append something to a comment, you might as well post another comment. The editing allows us to fix problems with the <pre> tag and the preview box, as we have seen troubles with lately, without having to post a string of comments correcting typos or other small errors.
Someone can't do any more than they could in posting a comment normally; the worst I can see happening is a new user changing their incorrect solution after the official one is posted or something, and even then there is the edit date.
If that worries you, perhaps to make sure that the feature is used only to correct errors, etc, you could only allow problem editing for 12 hours after it's posted or something.
One thing, though, I would suggest that the 'Edited date/time stamp' not be added if the problem has just been submitted, for half an hour or an hour or something, to allow people to fix display problems with their comments and not have it looks as if a solution was fixed later or something (although the actual time/date of the change will show otherwise, I imagine that will be overlooked a lot of the time). I can see using it quite often in place of the preview comment box, since that often doesn't work the way it should, but then a newly posted comment looks as if it was changed after it was posted. That's the only further suggestion I have. |