Jenny Turner
2004-10-28 07:17:21 |
When voting-type persons are TU/TD-ing
...can they see the solution or just the problem? |
Juggler
2004-10-28 08:45:21 |
Re: When voting-type persons are TU/TD-i
we only see the problem. |
Sam
2004-10-28 10:47:04 |
Re: When voting-type persons are TU/TD-i
...except in rare cases when we have questions about the problem, and the person who submitted it dun a runner, meaning that we can't ask them anything in the comments. Often in that case one of the scholars will look behind the curtain at the solution, and reprot back telling us if the problem makes sense as it is, or if it needs changing.
But for the other 99% of the time Juggler's right. The site would be no fun for us if we saw all the answers in advance. |
Jenny Turner
2004-10-28 11:58:43 |
Re: When voting-type persons are TU/TD-i
Ah. So it's probably best not to submit a problem to "Tricks" in which the trick is that the solver is directed to think there's no unique solution, when in fact there is?
|
Juggler
2004-10-28 13:09:25 |
Re: When voting-type persons are TU/TD-i
Jenny, if you have a problem, then post it where-ever you feel it needs to be, if it's a good problem but in the wrong place then one of the scholars can put it right. |
Gamer
2004-10-30 00:23:54 |
Re: When voting-type persons are TU/TD-ing
Actually I think only the director (Levik) can see the solution, so if you want us to clue us in it's a good idea to post a note for the queue. |
