All about flooble | fun stuff | Get a free chatterbox | Free JavaScript | Avatars    
perplexus dot info
Discussion Forums
Login: Password:Remember me: Sign up! | Forgot password

Forums > Commons
A place to come and discuss the features of this site, as well as suggest/request additions and modifications. Oh yeah, and Bug reports too.
chris
2003-03-23 19:22:28
What is

What is queue weight? I was looking at my pending problems and saw this. What does it mean?

TomM
2003-03-23 20:44:17
Re: What is

In order to move certain problems (especially those submitted by new members) through the waiting line (queue) faster, Levik has given the two oldest problems by each submitter a "heavier" "queue weight."

The full details are explained in the Queue Ranking and QW threads in the "Library" forum

levik
2003-03-24 01:56:36
Re: What is

Actually, since users Novices and Students don't have access to that forum, I should probably explain it here.

About a month ago, we reailzed that the queue has grown to an unmanagable size (we had over 200 pending problems then). At that point prolems were voted on and approved on a first come first serve basis. (It was, in other words, a true queue.) We realized that this is pretty bad for new users: somebody submitting a problem would have to wait for over six months before they saw it posted. They would lose interest and never come back to the site.

The problem was, most of the pending puzzles were submitted by the same person, so in effect, the new users were being penalized because of his generocity. So we added a new feature called the queue weight (QW). This allows more users to have their problems voted on and pushed, because now the problems are sorted by QW in ascending order. (That is ALL problems with QW of 1 come before any problem with QW of 2.) QW of each problem is recalculated every night in the following manner:

For each person with submitted problems, their first three get a QW of 1, next three - 2, etc.(It's possible we will consider decreasing this number to two problems or even one, if we see a lot of same people occupying the queue.)

chris
2003-03-24 05:57:44
Re: What is

I see. So this way more people get to see their problems on the site faster.

Tristan
2003-10-03 23:21:07
AHA!

I have finally found it! The thread that explains QW! There's so much in the forums, I knew it would be somewhere.

I'm posting this because QW may have changed since the time this was up at the top. I know that by now the number of QW 1's is only two, so there may have been other changes.

I'd also like to have more details. My first puzzle first appeared in the upper 60's. Does this mean that there are 60 other problems with QW 1? The way QW is described here, it seems to be flawed. Logically, if QW 1s ALL come before higher QWs, wouldn't puzzles from people like Ravi and Gamer never appear until there are less then 10 QW 1 puzzles? How would calculating QW every night change anything? Aren't puzzles the same QW for their whole queue time?

People may respond here and/or that FAQ page

TomM
2003-10-04 00:52:20
Re: Re-calculating QW

>>Logically, if QW 1s ALL come before higher QWs, wouldn't puzzles from people like Ravi and Gamer never appear until there are less then 10 QW 1 puzzles? How would calculating QW every night change anything? Aren't puzzles the same QW for their whole queue time?

Assume that Ravi has 10 puzzles in the queue. The first two are QW1, etc. One gets 3 Thumbs-up and is pushed, the other is determined to be a duplicate of a puzzle already posted, gets three thumbs down and is dropped. They are replaced in the queue by the next two QW1 puzzles (which are not Ravi's). Call them P1 and P2. These new puzzles get a couple of votes and other comments.

Then mid-night comes along (or whatever time levik schedules the re-calc). Ravi's two oldest remaining problems are now given QW1. Call them R1 and R2. If R1 is older than P1, it moves ahead of it in the queue, forcing P2 back into obscurity. If R2 is also older than P1, P1 also gets "bumped.

That's why there are usually really 12 or 13 puzzles in the "top ten" of the queue -- the ten (plus) puzzles available to be commented on and voted for.

Tristan
2003-10-04 10:28:30
Re: What is

I see, I must have missed a few points. I thought that the QW 1 puzzles were the first puzzles submitted, not the first ones submitted, still in the queue! (that would really create problems). And so also, the puzzles with same QW are sorted by age. It all makes sense now.

Copyright © 2002 - 2024 by Animus Pactum Consulting. All rights reserved. Privacy Information