All about flooble | fun stuff | Get a free chatterbox | Free JavaScript | Avatars    
perplexus dot info

Home > Probability
Pick a box! (Posted on 2002-03-28) Difficulty: 3 of 5
You are shown three boxes, and told that one of them contains a prize. You are then asked to pick one box, and if that box is the one with the prize, you will win it. After picking a box, you are shown that one of the other two boxes is empty, and offered a chance to change your selection.

Should you do this? Would changing your choice to the other remaining box affect your odds of winning? Why or why not?

  Submitted by levik    
Rating: 4.2857 (14 votes)
Solution: (Hide)
Switching your choice would actually double your odds, and would be the smart thing to do. Here's why:

Let's say you start off by picking an arbitrary box. Let's call it box (A). Let's also call the other two boxes (B) and (C). Since the chance of the prize being in a particular box is 1/3, your selected box, (A), will be the winner one out of three times.

Which means you will lose the other two times, when the prize will be in either box (B) or box (C). Now the problem states that you are shown that one of these boxes is empty. But of course one of them has to be empty since the prize cannot be in both of them. And of course the odds of the prize being in either (B) or (C) are not affected by revealing which box the prize is not in.

So let's say the box revealed to be empty is (B). If the chance of the prize being in either (B) or (C) is 2/3, and we know that it's definitely not in (B), that means that we can say that the probability is 2/3 that it is in (C) - and 1/3 that it is in (A).

Thus changing your choice raises your chance of winning from one out of three to two out of three.

You can see the statistics of this here.

Update: Here's a more intuitive explanation...

At the time you make your initial guess and pick one box, the prize is either contained in that box, or not contained in it.

If the prize is in the box you picked, changing your choice is obviously the wrong thing to do.

However, if you were initially wrong, then the prize is in one of the other two boxes. After one of those boxes is revealed to be empty, the prize will most definitely be in the last remaining box, so you should definitely switch

So you stay with your choice if you are initially correct, and switch if you were wrong. Now the chance that you were right with your first guess is 1/3, and that you were wrong - 2/3, so in two out of three cases a switch makes sense.

Comments: ( You must be logged in to post comments.)
  Subject Author Date
SolutionAlternate explanation of the solutiontomarken2009-03-25 11:53:52
SolutionTwo Solutionsowl2005-08-17 14:36:31
SolutionSolutionStephen Ticsay2005-04-16 04:08:18
re: Cool analogyyocko2005-03-08 07:38:34
Solution6/9Bractals2005-03-08 07:12:10
Agree with solution? Problem simplified?john2005-03-07 17:11:43
re: Cool analogyjohn2005-03-07 16:52:33
Cool analogyTristan2005-03-04 03:01:28
re: Flat out wrong logic in solution.Tristan2005-03-03 22:20:52
Flat out wrong logic in solution.john2005-03-03 18:15:56
re(4): YES! ~33/66! All possibilites shown!Dustin2005-03-03 00:15:47
re(3): NO! 50/50! All possibilites shown!Tristan2005-03-02 23:31:06
re(2): NO! 50/50! All possibilites shown!john2005-03-02 21:03:49
Disagree with solution!john2005-03-02 16:18:09
re(3): YES! ~33/66! All possibilites shown!john2005-03-02 16:08:25
re(2): YES! ~33/66! All possibilites shown!Dustin2005-03-01 17:42:05
re: NO! 50/50! All possibilites shown!Dustin2005-03-01 17:30:30
re: NO! 50/50! All possibilites shown!john2005-03-01 17:24:54
NO! 50/50! All possibilites shown!john2005-03-01 17:09:37
re: kinda easyjohn2005-03-01 16:21:47
re:owl2004-12-11 05:46:49
No SubjectIain2004-05-09 14:24:09
Some ThoughtsNo Subjectlogischer Verstand2004-05-02 20:53:08
maybeBilly Bob2004-03-28 10:29:41
Solutionkinda easyomar2004-02-21 15:31:40
No SubjectCory Taylor2002-12-17 10:17:09
re: hmmmlevik2002-11-06 10:14:07
Some Thoughtshmmmdanny2002-11-05 11:35:50
Some ThoughtsCome on guys!Arcus2002-10-29 09:25:40
re: 50% vs 67%levik2002-10-17 09:01:31
50% vs 67%Jim Lyon2002-10-16 13:08:30
re: Why 50% is not the answer.levik2002-08-15 10:16:15
HeyDulanjana2002-08-14 20:55:02
Why 50% is not the answer.Paul2002-08-14 11:14:20
50% is the ONLY answer.Mike2002-05-10 15:32:06
Math vs. PuzzlesChris2002-05-07 04:50:40
More infoJohn2002-05-01 06:46:13
More info to Re: NoJohn2002-05-01 06:44:48
Re: NoJohn2002-05-01 06:43:30
NoD Willson2002-04-23 22:19:13
Please log in:
Remember me:
Sign up! | Forgot password

Search body:
Forums (2)
Newest Problems
Random Problem
FAQ | About This Site
Site Statistics
New Comments (2)
Unsolved Problems
Top Rated Problems
This month's top
Most Commented On

Copyright © 2002 - 2020 by Animus Pactum Consulting. All rights reserved. Privacy Information