All about flooble | fun stuff | Get a free chatterbox | Free JavaScript | Avatars
 perplexus dot info

 Oddly Powered (Posted on 2013-10-25)
Given that N is an odd integer > 1 which is not divisible by 3.

Is floor(4N - (2+√2)N) always divisible by 112 for every possible value of N?
If so, prove it. Otherwise, provide a counterexample.

 No Solution Yet Submitted by K Sengupta Rating: 3.0000 (1 votes)

Comments: ( Back to comment list | You must be logged in to post comments.)
 Possible solution. Comment 1 of 1

The claim is true.  This is a somewhat lacklustre proof:

1.  Check that the proposition seems true using small values:
Start with the idea that floor(4^n - (2+《qrt(2))^n) = (4^n - (2+《qrt(2))^n - (2-sqrt(2))^n), the Pell-type expression being more convenient to manipulate.

2. Then a = (4^n - (2+《qrt(2))^n - (2-sqrt(2))^n)/112, 0<n<20 produces: {{a == 0, n == 1}, {a == 5, n == 5}, {a == 98, n == 7}, {a == 30888, n == 11}, {a == 522704, n == 13}, {a == 142999104, n == 17}, {a == 2333122176, n == 19}}

3. Looking at 4^n, it is easy to see that it is periodic mod112 with period 3 for n>1 and values: {16,64,32}.

4.  Looking at  a = (2+《qrt(2))^n +(2-sqrt(2))^n, 0<n<10 produces:
{{n == 1, x == 4}, {n == 2, x == 12}, {n == 3, x == 40}, {n == 4, x == 136}, {n == 5, x == 464}, {n == 6, x == 1584}, {n == 7, x == 5408}, {n == 8, x == 18464}, {n == 9, x == 63040}}.

5. By inspection, the integral recurrence relation for a is then clearly: a(n)= 4*a(n-1)-2*a(n-2), and we can fill up an Excel sheet with 'small' values. (To save space, this exercise is left to the reader).

6. It transpires that after a bumpy start, the expression (2+《qrt(2))^n +(2-sqrt(2))^n also settles down to period 6, mod112 with values: {16,16,32,96,96,80}. The two periods coincide to produce divisibility by 112 whenever n={6k-1},{6k+1}, but not otherwise.

7. Since 112=28*4  I strongly suspect that a more 'profound' solution exists, possibly along the lines of 'Quarting the Cube' (pid8287); unfortunately I was unable to identify the clinching expressions.

Edited on October 25, 2013, 1:45 pm
 Posted by broll on 2013-10-25 13:33:06

 Search: Search body:
Forums (0)