There are two urns, each with some numbered cards inside.
In urn A there are cards representing all 3-digit numbers (from 109 to 910 inclusively), having 10 as their sum of digits.
In urn B - all 3-digit numbers (from 119 to 920 inclusively), with 11 as their s.o.d.
Assuming you aim to randomly draw a prime number,
which urn would you choose?
What if there was a 3rd urn with s.o.d=15, would you consider it as a good choice?
(In reply to
re(3): computer assisted solution -remarki by Ady TZIDON)
Indeed there was a bug:extra NEXT's in the IF statements.
Corrected:
5 Digsum=10
10 for N=100 to 999
20 S=fnSod(N)
30 if S=Digsum and prmdiv(N)=N then inc Ct
35 if S=Digsum then print N;:inc Ct2
40 next
50 print:print Ct,Ct2,Ct/Ct2
60 end
1070 fnSOD(X)
1080 Sod=0
1090 S=cutspc(str(X))
1100 for I=1 to len(S)
1110 Sod=Sod+val(mid(S,I,1))
1120 next
1130 return(Sod)
OK
run
109 118 127 136 145 154 163 172 181 190 208 217 226 235 244 253 262 271 280 307 316 325 334 343 352 361 370 406 415 424 433 442 451 460 505 514 523 532 541 550 604 613 622 631 640 703 712 721 730 802 811 820 901 910
new stats:
12 out of 54 for prob 0.2222222222222222221
and for sod=11:
119 128 137 146 155 164 173 182 191 209 218 227 236 245 254 263 272 281 290 308 317 326 335 344 353 362 371 380 407 416 425 434 443 452 461 470 506 515 524 533 542 551 560 605 614 623 632 641 650 704 713 722 731 740 803 812 821 830 902 911 920
for stats:
13 out of 61 making prob = 0.2131147540983606557
These probabilities agree with snark's reported results.
Same choice of urn for best chances, as noted by snark.
|
Posted by Charlie
on 2013-01-11 01:57:35 |