How truthful a Rebel's statements are is unknown, except that they are not the same as those who are Knights, Liars, or Knaves. Thus, a rebel will never make just one or two statements; he will always make three or more.
A, B, C and D are four inhabitants of the planet, who are busy in a conversation when a visitor from a neighboring planet stops by and asks each of them their identity. They say:
Inhabitant A:
- My statements are not all truthful.
- We are overworked.
- We are all lucky to be here.
- We Realmamberians are favored by the gods.
Inhabitant B:
- I agree with A's third statement.
- Every time I see a visitor, I think maybe it is one of the gods, in disguise.
- I am doing more than my share of the work.
- My statements are all truthful.
Inhabitant C:
- My statements are all truthful.
- D's second statement is false.
- The gods do not visit us in disguise.
- We are all overworked.
Inhabitant D:
- C's first statement is truthful.
- B's third statement is truthful.
- My statements are all truthful.
- The gods frequently visit us in disguise.