All about flooble | fun stuff | Get a free chatterbox | Free JavaScript | Avatars    
perplexus dot info

Home > Logic
Fifty Bucks for a Dollar bill? (Posted on 2003-06-03) Difficulty: 3 of 5
I have a one dollar bill. there is a crowd of people around me. I hold it up and say that i will auction the one dollar bill off, and the dollar would go to the highest bidder.

The catch? the first AND second highest bidder both have to pay me whatever they bid. For example, if the bidding stops when someone bids 1.00 and the next person bids .95, then I get 1.95, and the winner gets nothing, the second person loses 95 cents.

What would you do if you were at this auction, and there had to be at least one bid? What is the "winning" strategy, assuming that everyone will want to do what is best for them?

  Submitted by Jonathan Waltz    
Rating: 3.9474 (19 votes)
Solution: (Hide)
Well, the only possibility is for the first person to bid one dollar. if i bid first, and bid on cent, then there will be someone who thinks that he can get it for two cents, so he will bid two. Well, i dont want to pay one cent and get nothing out of it, so i bid three cents.

This would go on and on, until the numbers get ridiculously huge, making the auctioneer incredibly rich. but, if the first person bids one dollar, then noone would want to bid higher than that, because they aren't paying any money, and because who would want to pay more than a dollar for a plain one dollar bill?

Comments: ( You must be logged in to post comments.)
  Subject Author Date
some thoughtsK Sengupta2007-06-28 12:11:27
Some Thoughtsre:greedc.e. blanz2006-01-04 15:20:01
GreedRajal2004-08-10 15:51:14
SolutionAlternate SolutionBilly Bob2004-03-28 10:37:33
SolutionLawrence2003-08-24 18:33:45
Some Thoughtsre: okLewis2003-07-11 22:08:33
Some Thoughtsokmike2003-07-11 13:39:49
re(3): If you know each other....Lewis2003-07-01 01:45:41
Hints/Tipsre(2): If you know each other....Gamer2003-06-30 13:30:17
re: If you know each other....Lewis2003-06-27 08:13:14
Some ThoughtsIf you know each other....Lewis2003-06-21 00:27:14
re:Sanjay2003-06-17 11:09:59
Some Thoughtsre: No SubjectLewis2003-06-16 07:23:52
No Subjectstephy2003-06-13 19:45:26
re(6): Dollars and SenseGamer2003-06-13 05:58:05
re(5): Dollars and Senseryan smith2003-06-12 15:52:38
re(4): Dollars and SenseSanjay2003-06-12 13:51:57
re(4): Dollars and SenseSanjay2003-06-12 13:42:18
re(3): Dollars and Senseryan smith2003-06-10 15:47:38
re(3): Dollars and Senseryan smith2003-06-10 15:43:19
re(2): Dollars and SenseSanjay2003-06-10 10:42:59
Some Thoughtsre(2): Dollars and SenseLewis2003-06-10 06:21:56
re: Dollars and Senseryan smith2003-06-09 21:48:21
Dollars and SenseSanjay2003-06-09 15:33:57
colludeCory Taylor2003-06-08 18:15:22
re(6): SolutionGamer2003-06-08 11:08:25
re(5): Solutionryan smith2003-06-07 19:03:19
re(4): SolutionTomM2003-06-07 09:21:30
Some Thoughtsre(3): SolutionLewis2003-06-07 07:51:51
re(2): SolutionTomM2003-06-07 07:29:54
Solutionre: Solutionryan smith2003-06-07 06:29:12
SolutionSolutionTomM2003-06-07 00:49:00
Solutionre: End the bidding wars!Lewis2003-06-06 22:49:04
re:Lewis2003-06-06 12:16:13
End the bidding wars!Gamer2003-06-06 06:00:54
re:Gamer2003-06-06 05:57:33
No Subjectblink2003-06-06 02:48:17
re(4): Here's an ideaBrian Smith2003-06-05 17:03:07
re(3): Here's an idearyan smith2003-06-05 16:44:24
re(2): Here's an idearyan smith2003-06-05 16:41:32
re: Here's an ideaBrian Smith2003-06-05 13:39:15
Here's an idearyan smith2003-06-05 00:00:00
re: Its all about the first bid.Dave2003-06-04 16:59:24
re: Bid Nothing?Gamer2003-06-04 16:46:29
Its all about the first bid.Brian Smith2003-06-04 14:16:05
Some ThoughtsHave some funDJ2003-06-04 12:44:25
SolutionSOLUTIONPickels2003-06-04 12:23:13
99¢ bid not safeBryan2003-06-04 10:35:12
No SubjectMatt2003-06-04 06:03:37
Bid Nothing?Sanjay2003-06-03 22:47:11
re: continuing with my thought..Lewis2003-06-03 21:36:43
continuing with my thought..Dave2003-06-03 17:25:10
quick question (and my thoughts)Dave2003-06-03 17:00:19
Thinking about making a profitBrian Smith2003-06-03 16:37:28
Initial thoughtnikki2003-06-03 12:57:32
re(5): Bang for the BuckGamer2003-06-03 12:35:31
re(4): Bang for the BuckCory Taylor2003-06-03 11:02:07
Solutionre(3): Bang for the BuckLewis2003-06-03 09:59:39
re(2): Bang for the BuckSanjay2003-06-03 09:37:45
re: Bang for the BuckJonny Doe2003-06-03 07:32:50
entrepreneurial answerCory Taylor2003-06-03 06:14:32
Bang for the BuckSanjay2003-06-03 06:08:13
re: Solution????Bryan2003-06-03 05:07:54
re: Solution????Cory Taylor2003-06-03 04:13:13
SolutionSolution????Jonny Doe2003-06-03 03:27:07
Friends or not?Gamer2003-06-03 02:08:47
Please log in:
Login:
Password:
Remember me:
Sign up! | Forgot password


Search:
Search body:
Forums (1)
Newest Problems
Random Problem
FAQ | About This Site
Site Statistics
New Comments (6)
Unsolved Problems
Top Rated Problems
This month's top
Most Commented On

Chatterbox:
Copyright © 2002 - 2024 by Animus Pactum Consulting. All rights reserved. Privacy Information