All about flooble | fun stuff | Get a free chatterbox | Free JavaScript | Avatars    
perplexus dot info

Home > Shapes > Geometry
3 circles in a sliced square (Posted on 2023-09-22) Difficulty: 3 of 5
A line is drawn in a square at a 45 degree angle to the sides but not through the center. 3 circles of equal radius are packed in the square: one in the isosceles right triangle on one side of the line and two in the pentagon on the other side.

Where should the line be placed to maximize the size of the circles?

No Solution Yet Submitted by Jer    
No Rating

Comments: ( Back to comment list | You must be logged in to post comments.)
Solution Solution | Comment 1 of 2
[Edit:  I just realized the 3 circles must be of equal radius,
so the following is not the solution, at all.   But it is a start.]

wlog, let this be a unit square.
Let ABCD be the square, the cutting line is parallel to BD, closer to C than A.
A (0,0), B (1,0), C (1,1), D (0,1)
Let d be the length of each short partial segments from B to the cutting line and D to the cutting line.

For a 45-45-90 triangle of side length 's',
the radius of the largest inscribed circle is: s*(1-√2/2)
the area of the largest inscribed circle is:
pi*s^2*(3 - 2√2)/2
And since 's' = 1-d, the first circle has area:
pi*(1-d)^2*(3 - 2√2)/2

But before figuring out the pentagon, figure out the area for a few simple cases:
case 1: d=1, the equilateral triangle is non existent, the "pentagon" is the whole square.
there are 2 circles each of radius (1-√2/2)
Total area:  pi*(3-2√2) about 0.5390120844526466

case 2:  d=0,  the cutting diagonal goes through B and D.  We have one circle of radius (1-√2/2) and 2 cirlces of radius (1-√2/2)/2
Total area:  pi*(3-2√2)/2  +  2*pi*(3-2√2)/8 = (3/4)*pi*(3-2√2)
   about 0.4042590633394849

Now, back to the general case.
The pentagon is split in half by drawing the diagonal of the original square (through the center) perpendicular to the original line drawn.  This makes 2 quadrilaterals that have angles 45-90-135-90.
One of these is bounded by:
x-axis between 0 and 1; y=x; x=1 between y=0 and y=d; y = -x + d + 1
The inscribed circle's radius is r.  The center of this circle has a y coordinate of r to make it tangent with the x-axis.  The center's x coordinate is (d+1)/1.  It's radius is:
r = (d+1)/(2(1+√2))
Using Desmos helped visualize this.

For small d, the largest circle will contact the 2 diagonals and the full length side, not the short segment.  From Desmos, it looks like when d = √2 - 1, the inscribed circle will also be tangent to the short segment.  For d > √2 - 1, the above analysis is not valid.

But assuming a smaller d value, the 2 circles in the pentagon each have:
r = (d+1)/(2(1+√2))
Area = (pi*(d+1)^2) / (4(3+2√2))
multiply top and bottom by (3-2√2)
Area = (pi*(d+1)^2)(3-2√2) / 4

The total area is:
(pi/2)*(3-2√2) * [ (1-d)^2 + (d+1)^2 ]
2(pi/2)*(3-2√2) * (d^2 + 1)
... and setting the derivative to zero will result in a negative value for d.
Suggesting the largest d gives the maximum area.
So choose d = √2-1
2(pi/2)*(3-2√2) * ((√2-1)^2 + 1)
pi*(3-2√2) * (2+1-2√2 + 1)
pi*(3-2√2) * (4-2√2)
pi*(12 - 6√2  - 8√2 + 8)
pi*(20 - 14√2) = ~0.6314919375787372

https://www.desmos.com/calculator/ez3ydfgubd

Edited on September 22, 2023, 1:53 pm
  Posted by Larry on 2023-09-22 11:39:35

Please log in:
Login:
Password:
Remember me:
Sign up! | Forgot password


Search:
Search body:
Forums (4)
Newest Problems
Random Problem
FAQ | About This Site
Site Statistics
New Comments (14)
Unsolved Problems
Top Rated Problems
This month's top
Most Commented On

Chatterbox:
Copyright © 2002 - 2024 by Animus Pactum Consulting. All rights reserved. Privacy Information