Assume that 50,000,000 votes are cast in the next U.S. presidential election.
What is the smallest number of these votes that a candidate could receive and still be elected president?
[Your answer need not be probable, but it should have at least one chance in 1,000,000 of actually happening.]
First, you can make the number as small as you please by having more than two candidates. Let's assume, though, that the question expects exactly two candidates (or at least only two that get a significant fraction of votes.)
You can win with only 13.8M votes or so like this:
Let's also assume that the number of votes cast in a particular state is proportional to the population of that state. (If some states have higher turnout than others, we can engineer an even bigger gap.)
These 12 states: CA, TX, NY, FL, PA, OH, IL, GA, NC, VA, WA, and NM collectively have 269 electoral votes, and a total population of ~150M and so generate ~22.4M votes
Imagine that there are two candidates, A and B. Suppose A gets no votes at all in these 12 states.
Now, the remaining 38 states have a population of 184M and so generate ~27.6M votes. If A gets one more vote than B in these states, then A wins those electoral votes. Roughly, that means A can win 271 electoral votes by having ~13.8M voters in these states.
Overall, then, A can win the electoral college vote with only 13.8/50 = 27.6% of the popular vote.
Now there are a few obvious flaws here over and above the assumptions about number of candidates and fraction of population who votes:
* It's unlikely that A would get ZERO votes in the twelve populous states. I don't know where the 1:1,000,000 mark is, but clearly the above analysis is a best case.
* There are a few states that award their electoral votes in proportion to the fraction of the popular vote received rather than all-or-nothing. I've ignored that here.
Despite these flaws, the bottom line of the analysis is still accurate -- you can become president with considerably less than 50% of the popular vote, even without a 3rd party candidate siphoning votes away.
|
Posted by Paul
on 2024-03-17 22:17:30 |