All about flooble | fun stuff | Get a free chatterbox | Free JavaScript | Avatars    
perplexus dot info

Home > Probability
Beat The Book (Posted on 2021-03-10) Difficulty: 3 of 5
An online sportsbook is advertising a “Risk Free” promotion for new users: If your first wager loses, you will be awarded a “free bet” in the amount of your wager (up to $1,000).

In reading the terms and conditions of the promotion, you note that unlike a normal wager, a “free bet” does not return the stake along with any winnings. e.g. if you wager $1,000 cash on a selection with odds of 1.95 and win, you’d get back $1,950 (your $1,000 stake is returned, plus $950 in winnings); if you’d placed a $1,000 “free bet” on that same selection, you’d only be paid the $950 in winnings.

For this puzzle make the following simplifying assumptions:
- The sportsbook reduces the fair odds of all of their selections by 2.5%. For example, the true odds on selection with a 50% probability of occurring should be 2.00. However the sportsbook pays only 2 * (1 - 0.025) = 1.95.
- The sportsbook knows the true probabilities of all events occurring, and uniformly prices all selections with the same 2.5% margin.
- The sportsbook offers a large enough variety of markets that any odds you seek are available for you to bet on.

a) Determine a strategy to maximize the expected value of this promotion.

b) Assuming you wanted to make this a truly risk-free proposition, maximize the amount of guaranteed profit you can get out of this promotion.

  Submitted by tomarken    
Rating: 4.5000 (2 votes)
Solution: (Hide)
a) Let x and y be the odds of the first cash bet and the subsequent free bet, respectively, and w be the amount of the wager.

There is a (0.975/x) probability you’ll win the first bet, which returns w*x.

There is a (1 – 0.975/x)*(0.975/y) probability that you’ll lose the first bet and then win the free bet, which returns w*(y-1). Otherwise you lose both bets, which returns 0.

Your expected profit is then (0.975/x)*(wx) + (1 – 0.975/x)*(0.975/y)*w*(y-1) - w.

Some algebra makes this (0.950625/xy – 0.950625/x – 0.975/y + 0.95) * w.

This approaches 0.95w as x and y go to infinity. So you want to place the largest possible bet ($1,000) at the longest possible odds, and if it loses do the same with the free bet - your expected profit by doing so approaches $950. (By contrast, if you place the bets at the shortest possible odds, i.e. x = y = 1.0, your expected loss is -$25, as implied by the margin.)

b) Of course, the expected value in (a) is based on a small chance of winning a lot of money, offset by a very high probability of simply losing your $1,000. If we were risk-averse and wanted to guarantee a profit, let’s work backwards.

Assuming we have a $1,000 free bet, we could place it on a selection and then wager an amount of cash on the opposite selection such that either outcome returns the same amount (we’re looking for the maximum guaranteed amount, so if they didn’t return the same amount there would be a nonzero chance we’d get the smaller amount).

Given the odds of a selection, we can compute the corresponding odds of their opponent by adding back the 2.5% margin, computing the implied probability, subtracting from 1 and then applying 2.5% margin back to the result. So if the odds on a selection are x, the odds on their opponent would be 0.975 / (1 – 0.975/x).

With a bit more algebra we find that for a selection with odds of x, we can guarantee ourselves a profit P = 1025.64 – 25.64x – 1000/x. If we take the derivative and set it equal to 0 we find that P is maximum when x ~= 6.25.

We could therefore place a $1,000 free bet at odds of 6.25, and wager $4,544.62 on their opponent at odds of 1.155. Either outcome returns $5,250 for a net profit of $705.38.

Stepping back, we want to ensure the same return if we don’t get the free bet, so we would make our first wager of $1,000 cash on a selection at odds of 5.25, and place a subsequent wager of $3,795.51 on their opponent at odds of 1.197. If the first wager wins we get back $5,250; if it loses we get back $4,544.62 and receive a free bet convertible into an additional $705.38.

Either way we’ve wagered a total of $4,795.51 in cash and are guaranteed to receive $5,250 back, for a net profit of $454.49.

Comments: ( You must be logged in to post comments.)
  Subject Author Date
re(2): Possible Solutionbroll2022-05-23 00:01:40
Hints/Tipsre: Guaranteed Profit (spoiler)tomarken2021-03-17 12:01:17
SolutionGuaranteed Profit (spoiler)Steve Herman2021-03-17 10:35:15
Hints/TipsPosting the Solution Soontomarken2021-03-17 09:35:28
Hints/Tipsre: Possible Solutiontomarken2021-03-12 08:29:06
Some ThoughtsPossible Solutionbroll2021-03-10 20:17:24
re: Almost Guaranteed profit?tomarken2021-03-10 18:44:23
re: Almost Guaranteed profit?Charlie2021-03-10 18:33:30
Some ThoughtsAlmost Guaranteed profit?Steve Herman2021-03-10 18:21:05
Some Thoughtscomputer calculationsCharlie2021-03-10 12:39:51
Please log in:
Login:
Password:
Remember me:
Sign up! | Forgot password


Search:
Search body:
Forums (1)
Newest Problems
Random Problem
FAQ | About This Site
Site Statistics
New Comments (6)
Unsolved Problems
Top Rated Problems
This month's top
Most Commented On

Chatterbox:
Copyright © 2002 - 2024 by Animus Pactum Consulting. All rights reserved. Privacy Information