All about flooble | fun stuff | Get a free chatterbox | Free JavaScript | Avatars    
perplexus dot info

Home > General
The Intrepid Ant (Posted on 2002-10-03) Difficulty: 3 of 5
A rubber band is 1 meter long. An ant starts at one end, crawling at 1 millimeter per second. At the end of each second, the rubber band is instantaneously stretched by an additional meter. (So, at the end of the nth second, the rubber band becomes n+1 meters long.)

Does the ant ever reach the far end of the band? If so, when?

  Submitted by Jim Lyon    
Rating: 4.4375 (16 votes)
Solution: (Hide)
During the first second, the ant traverses 1/1000 of the band. When the band stretches, he's still 1/1000 of the way to the end. During the second second, the band is 2 meters long, so he only traverses 1/2000 of the band. In general, during the nth second the ant traverses 1/(1000*n) of the rubber band. So, for the time up to and through the nth second, he has traversed:

1/1000 + 1/2000 + 1/3000 + ... + 1/(1000*n)

As n grows large, this series increases without bound. When the value of this series reaches 1, the ant will be at the far end of the rubber band. Therefore, mathematically speaking, the ant will reach the end.

The series above takes as many terms to reach one as the following series takes to reach 1000:

1/1 + 1/2 + 1/3 + ...

This takes between e^999 and e^1000 terms. So, the ant takes roughly e^1000 seconds to reach the end.

But wait. e^1000 seconds is inconcievably huge, roughly 10^426 years. By way of comparison, the universe is only about 10^10 years old, and is expected to suffer complete heat death before 10^100 years.

So yes, the ant gets there, but it takes him 10^326 universe lifetimes to do so. At the end of this time, the rubber band is 10^426 meters, or 10^418 light-years long. Assuming that the rubber band weighs 10 grams (reasonable for a 1 meter band), it has about 10^24 atoms, and the mean distance between atoms when fully stretched is 10^394 light-years. The known size of the universe is only about 10^10 light-years, so the rubber band is stretched much further than that.

All of which goes to show that, mathematics notwithstanding, the ant will never reach the end.

Comments: ( You must be logged in to post comments.)
  Subject Author Date
Puzzle Thoughts K Sengupta2023-08-06 21:55:50
Ok, not it's notrich harran2004-03-24 06:27:28
Simple solution (and _this_ one is correct)rich harran2004-03-23 04:31:27
a question of logic, my perceptiongavin2003-03-31 02:47:39
re: Please, find the mistake!TomM2003-02-20 11:36:41
QuestionPlease, find the mistake!gary2003-02-20 10:40:37
re: simple solutionJaved Iqbal2003-02-17 04:54:24
hmmm, good questionKenneth2002-11-05 10:39:30
No SubjectAmanda2002-10-09 11:48:55
re(5): The backward antJim Lyon2002-10-08 05:51:13
re(4): The backward antCheradenine2002-10-08 03:42:40
re(3): The backward antfriedlinguini2002-10-08 03:26:29
re(2): The backward antCheradenine2002-10-08 03:06:08
re(2): The backward antJim Lyon2002-10-07 11:16:27
re: The backward antBrad Hack2002-10-07 06:57:39
Solutionre(3): The backward antTomM2002-10-05 11:37:01
Some Thoughtsre(2): The backward antAeternus2002-10-04 18:42:19
re: The backward antAeternus2002-10-04 05:15:08
Some Thoughtslogarithmic?Cheradenine2002-10-04 01:33:10
Some ThoughtsThe backward antTomM2002-10-03 19:43:33
re: some mathTomM2002-10-03 19:26:38
some mathJames D Brown2002-10-03 16:42:01
re(2): No SubjectTomM2002-10-03 10:00:30
Some ThoughtsFirst StepsTomM2002-10-03 09:54:11
Questionre: No Subjectlevik2002-10-03 08:48:06
Some ThoughtsNo SubjectCheradenine2002-10-03 07:57:24
Please log in:
Login:
Password:
Remember me:
Sign up! | Forgot password


Search:
Search body:
Forums (0)
Newest Problems
Random Problem
FAQ | About This Site
Site Statistics
New Comments (13)
Unsolved Problems
Top Rated Problems
This month's top
Most Commented On

Chatterbox:
Copyright © 2002 - 2024 by Animus Pactum Consulting. All rights reserved. Privacy Information