All about flooble | fun stuff | Get a free chatterbox | Free JavaScript | Avatars
 perplexus dot info

 Dimensions of a box (Posted on 2009-05-15)
A rectangular box with no top must have a volume of 2,500 cm3.

Three different materials will be used in the construction of this box. The bottom will be made out of material that costs 5 cents/cm2, the front and back will be made out of material that costs 4 cents/cm2, and material for the two sides costs 2 cents/cm2.

What are the dimensions of the box (with volume 2,500 cm3) that will minimize the total cost of the materials?

 See The Solution Submitted by pcbouhid No Rating

Comments: ( Back to comment list | You must be logged in to post comments.)
 solution without calculus Comment 3 of 3 |

After having done a number of problems of this type, I realized there was a generalization that could be made on minimizing the cost for a given volume: the total cost of top and bottom should equal the total cost of front and back and also equal the total cost of the left and right sides.

Let d, w and h be the depth, width and height respectively.

5 dw = 8 hw = 4 dh

(two of the dimension-pairs' costs have been doubled from the material costs as opposite faces are considered together; the bottom is not matched with a top, however, so the 5 cents / cm^2 stands.)

5 dw = 8 hw
5 d = 8 h

8 hw = 4 dh
8 w = 4 d
2 w = d

5 dw = 4 dh
5 w = 4 h

also, wdh = 2500

Converting the last to just w:

w(2w)(5w/4) = 2500
10 w^3 / 4 = 2500
w^3 = 1000
w = 10
d = 20
h = 50/4 = 12.5

The check below of the vicinity (w and d at the given values surrounded by +/- 1 mm) of the answer in terms of dollar cost shows indeed a local minimum of cost here:

30.00176   30.00101   30.00076
30.00025   30.00000   30.00025
30.00074   30.00099   30.00174

DEFDBL A-Z
FOR w = 9.9# TO 10.11# STEP .1#
FOR d = 19.9# TO 20.11# STEP .1#
h = 2500 / (w * d)
PRINT USING "#####.#####"; (5 * w * d + 8 * w * h + 4 * d * h) / 100;
NEXT d
PRINT
NEXT w
PRINT

So the box is 10 cm wide, 20 cm deep and 12.5 cm high.

 Posted by Charlie on 2009-05-15 14:09:30

 Search: Search body:
Forums (0)