All about flooble | fun stuff | Get a free chatterbox | Free JavaScript | Avatars
 perplexus dot info

 Return to Treasure Island (Posted on 2012-04-05)

'Arr, ' said Long John Silver, 'Arr, arr,' by way of clearing his throat, before addressing his 9 remaining companions.

'We've sailed the seas for 7 long years, and plundered a pirate hoard, and the time has come to divvy the loot at last. It goes without saying that each of you lubbers wants all the treasure he can lay his hands on.'

'Now, as ye know, the Rules of the Sea require that the Captain shall propose a division, and all then vote, democratical-like; if the proposal be passed, then all take accordingly. If the lots cast be tied, the Captain votes again, to break the tie. But if the division be rejected, the Captain forfeits his share, and the right to propose passes to the next in rank, and so on until a division be agreed at last.'

Now gather round me hearties, and listen to me proposal, according to rank:

Long John Silver, Cook and Captain: 75 shares
Abe the Master: 1 share.
Ben the Mate: 1 share
Caleb the Gunner: 1 share
Dave the Able: 1 share
Eben the Bosun: 1 share
Fergus the Feeble: 2 shares
Gabe the Gimpy: 4 shares
Ham the Hopeless: 6 shares
Jesse the Cabinperson: 8 shares

'I'm sure you'll agree, lads, I've done you all proud.'

Of course, it's endlessly debatable whether Long John's proposal is fair; but should his proposal be carried, or not?

 No Solution Yet Submitted by broll No Rating

Previous (in Just Math) : Point to 2012
Next (in Numbers) : The wine is so-so, but...
Comments: ( Back to comment list | You must be logged in to post comments.)
 answer | Comment 10 of 14 |
If each companion would opt for 1 share over a risk of receiving 0 shares, then Long John Silver's proposal should carry. The Captain could have offered Ben, Caleb, Dave and Eben only 1 share each and taken 96 shares for himself and the proposal would be more shares then those four could acertain for themselves.
The Captain is accordingly generous as he only needed four of his companions to vote with him.
 Posted by Dej Mar on 2012-04-06 15:38:33

 Search: Search body:
Forums (0)