All about flooble | fun stuff | Get a free chatterbox | Free JavaScript | Avatars    
perplexus dot info
Home > Paradoxes
These problems may or may not have an actual solution. Some of them are flat out contradictions, some lead you into infinite loops of logic.
Difficulty: 3 of 5 Latest: Majority Opinion Rating: 4.50
A defendant is on trial for murder. He will be found guilty if his actions are judged to have been deliberate, and premeditated. The jurors find as follows:

Juror #. 	Deliberate?	Premeditated?
Juror 1:	No      	Yes
Juror 2:	No      	Yes
Juror 3:	Yes     	No
Juror 4:	No      	Yes
Juror 5:	Yes     	Yes
Juror 6:	Yes     	No
Juror 7:	Yes     	Yes
Juror 8:	No      	Yes
Juror 9:	Yes     	No
Juror 10:	Yes     	No
Juror 11:	Yes     	Yes
Juror 12:	Yes     	Yes

A majority believe it was deliberate, and a majority believe it was premeditated, so the man is given the death penalty.

In subsequent interviews, the jurors are asked if they think the man should have received the death penalty and a majority of them say no.

How can this be? Was the man wrongfully convicted?

(Solution Posted, 3 Comments) Submitted on 2021-05-05 by tomarken   
Page 1 of 3   next >>    
Difficulty: 1 of 5Vive la petite différence! | Rating: 4.00
Posted on 2015-04-06 by Ady TZIDON (No Solution Yet, 3 Comments)
Difficulty: 3 of 5Friendship paradox | Rating: 4.00
Posted on 2014-10-31 by Ady TZIDON (No Solution Yet, 4 Comments)
Difficulty: 3 of 5The Exclusive Club | Rating: 5.00
Posted on 2013-07-01 by Math Man (No Solution Yet, 8 Comments)
Difficulty: 1 of 5All in the Family | Rating: 2.33
Posted on 2008-05-26 by FrankM (Solution Posted, 10 Comments)
Difficulty: 2 of 5Poker, solved | Rating: 3.50
Posted on 2008-03-29 by FrankM (Solution Posted, 11 Comments)
Difficulty: 4 of 5Forced Win, Forced Loss, or Neutral? | Rating: 3.50
Posted on 2008-02-08 by FrankM (Solution Posted, 16 Comments)
Difficulty: 3 of 5Hell Hath No Fury ... | Rating: 3.67
Posted on 2007-04-12 by Vernon Lewis (Solution Posted, 9 Comments)
Difficulty: 3 of 5Torus paradox | Rating: 4.40
Posted on 2007-01-02 by Tristan (Solution Posted, 7 Comments)
Difficulty: 2 of 5The Game | Rating: 4.00
Posted on 2006-12-14 by Rob (No Solution Yet, 14 Comments)
Difficulty: 3 of 5Are all complex numbers real? | Rating: 3.75
Posted on 2006-08-24 by atheron (No Solution Yet, 14 Comments)
Difficulty: 3 of 5Expect the unexpected | Rating: 3.36
Posted on 2006-02-15 by Paddy (Solution Posted, 32 Comments)
Difficulty: 3 of 5The Grass is Always Greener II | Rating: 3.83
Posted on 2005-08-11 by Sam (No Solution Yet, 7 Comments)
Difficulty: 3 of 5It is infinite if it isn't? | Rating: 3.00
Posted on 2005-04-12 by Old Original Oskar! (Solution Posted, 35 Comments)
Difficulty: 4 of 5Provably unprovable? | Rating: 3.42
Posted on 2004-08-22 by Federico Kereki (Solution Posted, 36 Comments)
Please log in:
Login:
Password:
Remember me:
Sign up! | Forgot password


Search:
Search body:
Forums (2)
Newest Problems
Random Problem
FAQ | About This Site
Site Statistics
New Comments (4)
Unsolved Problems
Top Rated Problems
This month's top
Most Commented On

Chatterbox:
Copyright © 2002 - 2021 by Animus Pactum Consulting. All rights reserved. Privacy Information